Contact me !

If you need to contact me , please write to me to this email ID : manjupadmasekar@yahoo.com. I will be happy to help.

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Does HLA sharing cause miscarriage ?


I recently heard from one of my friend who is going through IVF to have her child. In the course of her treatment , she went through two pregnancy losses, one at 12 weeks and one at 5 weeks. As usual, a battery of tests were performed on her by her IVF specialist to find out where the fault lay– why did the miscarriage happen ? Of the several tests performed on her, two tests came back positive. She was told her NK cells in uterus are elevated ; and that  her HLA haplotype (what the heck is that?) was very similar to her husband’s. On seeing her results, her doctor told her that it was a waste of time and energy in trying to get pregnant via IVF. He told her that she would never succeed in carrying a baby to term ; and that she needs a surrogate to carry the baby.
This was a great shock for a woman who was already going through hell in order to have a baby ? Going through IVF is a physically and emotionally draining pursuit. Facing a miscarriage after successful IVF is heart-wrenching. In this situation, how will you react when you are told that there are some killer cells in your uterus which are waiting to devour your precious embryo ? How would you feel when a doctor tells you that you share so much in common with your husband that you cannot carry a baby to term ?Normally, when someone tells you that you have something in common with your partner , you feel happy , but now there is a person telling you that too much sharing means that your joy of having your baby is at stake.
These kinds of diagnoses steal your confidence and the trust you have in your reproductive system and your ability to carry a baby! . They make you miserable,  as you do not know do what to do next. I am sure many of us are completely clueless about what HLA is and what natural killer cells (scary name !) are – I was , even though I am a biologist In fact I  bet that most doctors who perform such complicated tests on you will be unable to explain to you what HLA is ; and how it is connected to miscarriages !If you insist on knowing more, you will be provided with a pamphlet which is full of Greek and Latin.
You wonder if there are any treatment options which will help you to have your baby; and you also start doubting – do I really need to treat this condition - can any of this be true. When you can’t analyze the situation rationally and make a well-informed decision ; and when you have to rely on your doctor for making decisions about your further treatment options (especially when the treatment may cost you an arm and leg , and you are uncertain if the doctor himself understands what is happening) , you are sure to feel handicapped, angry and scared !
This article is intended to explain in simple terms what HLA is all about . Does HLA sharing really cause pregnancy losses ?Do the treatments employed to treat such a diagnosis help patients to carry their baby to term ? Do you really need to treat such a diagnosis ?
Let me start with a little bit of scientific background. Don’t let your eye glaze over – stay with me please – it’s an interesting journey and you’ll enjoy the ride. I’ll try to make it as painless as possible !

   

What is HLA ?


HLA stands for “Human Leucocyte Antigen”. They are a group of proteins which are expressed on the surface of almost all the cells in our body. HLA is also called as Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC). The genes (stretches of DNA ) which encode for HLA proteins are present in chromosome 6 (we have 46 chromosomes- 23 pairs !).
HLA genes are classified into class I, class II and class III. Class I genes encode for HLA- A, HLA- B and HLA- C proteins. These proteins are present in most cells of our body. Class I region also contains genes which give rise to HLA-E, HLA-F, HLA-G proteins. Class II genes encode HLA-DP, HLA-DQ and HLA-DR proteins. These proteins are present mainly in our immune system cells like B-lymphocytes, macrophages, T-lymphocytes etc. Class III genes encode components of our complement system (a group of proteins which function in our immune system)

We inherit half of our HLA genes from mother and other half from the father. Each person receives one set of HLA genes (HLA haplotype) from either parent.

 

 

 


 




HLA genes are highly variable


The genes that code for HLA proteins are highly variable. Thus, the HLA-A gene is not the same in everyone. They carry minute differences in them , as a result of which they produce proteins which are very different too. The HLA-A gene contains  2,188 variants and these are called alleles of HLA-A. There are 1,571 different varieties of HLA-A protein produced in humans (not all gene variants end up producing a different protein; hence the number of proteins is not equal to the number of gene variants). Each of us carry a pair of HLA-A gene and have only two variants (alleles) of the HLA-A gene. These 2 alleles can be any of the 2,188 variants present. For example if you assign each allele of HLA-A gene with a numerical name from 1-2,188, then I can have HLA-A allele HLA-A* 21 and HLA-A *892 (usually represented like this  : HLA-A*21.892) and my husband might have HLA-A*01 and HLA-A*1076 ( the scientific shorthand for this is HLA-A* 01,1076) This is the same for all other HLA genes as well - HLA-B, HLA-C, HLA-DP, HLA-DQ or HLA-DR. If you understand this , you will be able to make sense of your HLA typing result. 


HLA-A*02, 24

HLA – prefix
A-gene name

02 and 24 – alleles of HLA A (variants of HLA-A gene)

 

What is the function of HLA in human body ?


There are more microbes in this world than humans and there is a constant war going on between them.  Microbes try to attack us all the time and we have to fight them in order to prevent diseases. Just like police searching for thieves, special cells are constantly patrolling our body in search of harmful microbes like bacteria and viruses which can hide within us. If a thief hides within a house,  someone in the house should tell the police that the thief is hiding inside , so the police can trach him down. Likewise, when a microorganism enters and hides in our body , there should be some alerting system which should tell our immune cells ( the cells in our body which fight against microbes and kill them) that a particular cell is infected with a microbe and that they should destroy the microbe or the entire cell , in order to protect the other cells of our body. This is the job of the HLA molecules! HLA proteins help our immune system to identify microbes and thus help to kill them.

 Let’s look at this in more detail. When a cell is infected with a virus, some viruses are killed and broken down into pieces by the infected cell’s machinery . A part of the virus (a protein molecule also called an antigen ) is presented by the HLA class I molecule (which is present on the cell’s surface ) to the cytotoxic T cells of the body’s immune system . The T cell has the power to destroy an infected cell and this is how the immune system can identify which particular cell is infected , allowing the immune system to selectively destroy that cell , along with the invading virus.Similarly, when bacteria enter our body , special cells of our immune system engulf the bacteria, digest them and present the bacterial protein to helper T cells (immune cells which coax other immune cells to produce antibodies which will eventually destroy the bacteria) , with the help of the HLA class II molecule. This means HLA helps in telling our body’s immune system that our body is under attack by microbes, and it helps in recruiting and activating the immune cells to fight this attack . Any microbial protein will be identified by our immune system only when that microbial antigen is presented to the immune cells by the HLA proteins of our own body !This is the reason why HLA genes have so many variants. This large variety of HLA proteins helps in presenting different microbial antigens to the immune cells more effectively. If all humans carried  the same HLA molecules, some new virus or bacteria which cannot be presented effectively to our immune cells would spread quickly and destroy the entire human race ! The more the variety in HLA proteins , the greater the chances that the human race will survive a microbial attack ! There are currently 8,949 HLA gene variants identified in humans ; and this number is rapidly expanding too !



 The human immune system detects foreign cells with the help of cell-surface proteins called human leukocyte antigens (HLAs). Each person's cells carry a particular set of HLA molecules — the person's HLA type — which bind fragments of virus or bacterial protein and 'present' them to T cells, the immune cells that recognize and attack infected cells.


HLA is responsible for the immune rejection or immune acceptance of transplanted organs

Every human carries his own set of HLA proteins in his cells, half of which come from the mother and half from the father. If my kidney fails to function , I need a kidney transplant. However, I cannot get a kidney from anybody - I need a kidney donor whose HLA proteins match mine. Foreign (non-self) HLA molecules are readily recognized by my immune cells. Any foreign HLA molecule identified by the immune cells alerts my immune system to mount an attack against that particular tissue or organ,  because anything foreign is considered to be dangerous by our immune system. This is why the same immune system which protects our body from harmful microorganisms also prevents us from getting a potentially life-saving organ donation from a stranger. In order for any transplant (liver, skin, kidney transplant etc) to be successful , the HLA molecules present in the transplant recipient must be similar to the donor. This is why HLA typing is done before any transplantation procedure in order to identify the perfect donor. This is why HLA is also known as Major Histocompatibility (Histo = tissue) complex. Tissue compatibility during transplantation is decided based on HLA.

Since HLA genes are highly variable (remember, there are 8,949 HLA gene variants!) , it is very difficult to find a donor who matches the recipient. Only identical ( monozygotic ) twins have identical HLA proteins in their cells. Your sibling has only a 1 in 4 chance of being an identical HLA match for you. 

How does HLA comes into play in reproductive biology ?

A human fetus receives half of the genes from its mother and half from its father. This means a fetus expresses HLA proteins which are different from its mother ( because 50% of HLA proteins in a fetus come from the father ). If a fetus is not an identical HLA match to its mother , then why doesn’t the mother’s immune system reject the fetus during her pregnancy ? After all, if the son tried to donate a kidney to his mother after birth, there’s a high probability that this would be rejected ! (Remember, HLA mismatch is the strongest predictor of transplant rejection).  

If a HLA mismatched organ is rejected by the recipient’s immune system, then you would quite logically assume that if your husband carries the same HLA molecules as you do, then the chance of your immune system attacking your fetus is less , because the fetus carries the identical HLA molecules you have. But reproductive immunology theory says exactly the opposite !

How is an HLA incompatible fetus carried by the mother ?

A scientist named Wegmann in 1984 proposed a theory called “immunotrophic theory” to explain the paradox of how the maternal immune system accepts a fetus which is not genetically identical to hers. The theory states that recognition of the foreign antigen ( the paternal HLA) by the mother’s immune system is “ good “ for the fetus , because it causes the maternal immune system to produce protective cytokines ( such as G-CSF),which enhance implantation, promote the growth of trophoblastic cells and help in sustaining pregnancy. Reproductive immunologists suggest that recognition of foreign fetal antigens (mainly paternal HLA) by the mother’s immune system is necessary for eliciting a “protective” immune response ( such as the production of protective “blocking antibodies” , which protect the fetus from immune rejection), and this actually helps in the survival and development of fetus.  
If HLA incompatibility between the mother and fetus helps in embryo implantation and growth, then won’t HLA compatibility between mother and fetus lead to harmful pregnancy outcomes ? This is the question which prompted scientists to study the association between HLA sharing between partners and recurrent pregnancy loss.

HLA sharing between partners and fetal loss – what do the scientific studies say ?

This is a highly controversial topic among the scientific community ! One group states that HLA similarity (HLA compatibility) between the mother and fetus disrupts the proper cytokine signals and hence the mother’s immune cells are activated abnormally, leading ultimately to the death of the fetus. (PMID: 7762569 PMID: 8296846 PMID: 8207709 PMID: 1729895 PMID: 3860403 PMID: 10336015 PMID: 1771630

The other group refutes this hypothesis and argues that their scientific findings do not support the notion that HLA compatibility between mother and fetus (HLA sharing between partners)  can cause recurrent spontaneous abortion. (PMID:2658473 PMID:3477351 PMID:15713211 PMID: 20492598PMID:11530859 PMID:8579756 PMID:1534444 PMID:20605049 PMID: 20566486 PMID: 8839135 PMID: 1358093 PMID: 3245544)


“Everything must be taken into account. If the fact will not fit the theory---let the theory go.”

― Agatha Christie


Studies which support the hypothesis that HLA sharing between partners causes fetal loss have severe limitations in their experimental design

Imagine you want to ascertain whether coffee drinking leads to heart attacks in humans.  You select 100 people who suffered a heart attack and 100 who didn’t. Then you ask how many in the heart attack group drink coffee , and compare this with the number of coffee drinkers in the non-heart attack group. If you find more coffee drinkers in the heart attack group , you conclude that drinking coffee leads to heart attack. This kind of study design ( called a retrospective study) is extremely flawed - 100 people are not enough to study the entire population. If you conduct such a study 10 times , the probability of finding more coffee drinkers in heart attack group simply by chance is 50 %. This means that if 10 scientists conduct such a study, 5 will report that there is an association between coffee drinking and heart attacks and the other 5 will say that there is no association ! This is what exactly happened in studies which are designed to find whether HLA sharing between partners causes pregnancy loss !

A better way to do the study would be to follow  10,000 people who drink coffee ; and 10,000 people who do not drink , to see how many in each group suffer from a heart attack over a period of time. This is called a prospective study – but is much more complex and expensive to perform ! 

About 3 % of women suffer from recurrent spontaneous abortion (RSA). RSA is defined as 3 or more miscarriages that occur before 20 weeks of gestation. Scientists who studied the association between HLA sharing and fetal loss, studied couples who had had RSA ; and compared their degree of HLA sharing with normal fertile couples who had had no pregnancy losses. If they found more HLA sharing between partners in the RSA group , they concluded that RSA is caused because of HLA sharing ! Because the sample size used for the studies is very small , they have severe limitations in their design, which is why you should take their results with a generous pinch of salt. Keep in mind that they are many other genes which are involved in a baby’s development , and defects in these can cause miscarriage too. The studies conducted didn’t ( and can’t!) take into account all these confounding factors. 

So, if there are studies which both support and refute the hypothesis , how do I interpret the scientific data ?

 

“In questions of science, the authority of a thousand is not worth the humble reasoning of a single individual.”

― Galileo Galilei


Here is where we should use our common sense ! We have so many inbreeding communities in the real world. Endogamy (practice of marrying within a specific ethnic group, class, or social group) is still common in many cultures and ethnic groups (Middle East, Assyrians, Jews, Yazidi Kurds, Muslims, Knanaya Christians, Hindus). If a population is inbred , then there is a high chance that partners share their HLA haplotype. Do such inbred communities suffer from RSA and infertility ? For example, India has several communities where inbreeding ( marriage between uncle and niece ; and marriage between first cousins)  is very common.  This study (PMID: 11874619) conducted on an Indian community which practices consanguineous marriages failed to identify any overall adverse effect of inbreeding on fertility. The results of many such studies showed that consanguineous couples actually had more children ! In India, marriages with first cousins ( who have a 1 in 16 chance of being HLA identical ) have been practiced for centuries in many communities ; and these communities have flourished. If such marriages affected human reproduction adversely, the communities would have stopped following practices which were harmful.

Some more interesting information about HLA

When HLA testing is performed in the lab on you and your partner, they mostly check for compatibility between HLA-A, HLA-B, HLA-C, HLA-DQ etc. Do you know that these HLAs are not even expressed in the trophoblastic cells that come in contact with the mother’s immune system ? The only HLA type that is expressed on trophoblast cells is HLA-G ! Doesn’t this simple truth tell us many things ?

Should I consider paternal lymphocyte immunization therapy for “treating” the HLA sharing between me and my partner ?

 

If your doctor has suggested you this therapy, ask for the mode of action of this therapy and possible adverse events – most probably he will not know because the scientific community doesn’t know too !


Paternal lymphocyte immunotherapy has been used for treating RSA patients. It was hypothesized (one of the many existing hypothesis!) that the inability to build protective antibodies against fetal HLA (because of HLA similarity between mother and fetus as a result of the HLA sharing between the parents ) led to overactive NK cells and other immune cells , which killed the embryo and led to fetal loss. These antibodies are produced in a normal pregnancy, where they control and regulate the overactive NK cells , and protect the pregnancy from attack by them.

In Lymphocyte Immunization Therapy (LIT) your partner’s lymphocytes are isolated from his blood and injected under your skin , so that you can mount an effective immune response against the MHC molecules which his lymphocytes carry. The immune cells which are produced in your body against the MHC molecules are thought to protect the pregnancy.

These publication (PMID: 16625529) (PMID: 22349103) states that such unproven therapies do not provide any significant beneficial effect than placebo. 

There are also studies which show that paternal lymphocyte therapy can cause adverse effect to mother and fetus !(PMID: 21062364 PMID: 1453393 PMID: 10708244)

After comparing the evidence for and against the concept of HLA sharing and recurrent spontaneous abortion , I am convinced that the diagnosis of HLA sharing between partners , and the paternal lymphocyte therapy which is used as “treatment” has little scientific validity ! It appears to be more of a pseudoscience than a proven scientific theory to be taken too seriously.

Should I undergo therapy for HLA sharing ?

If you suffer from recurrent abortions and do not know what to do next , you may be desperate enough to try every possible therapy under the sun before giving up . You maybe willing to be an experimental guinea pig, since there is very little modern medicine can offer in the form of treatment for this distressing disorder. You may be willing to undergo unproven therapies , and this is quite understandable.  Even if you do decide to do so, please understand that such therapies have only anecdotal success stories , and are not a magical cure for your condition ! Over 50% of women who have had 3 or more miscarriages eventually achieve a successful pregnancy without any medical intervention, with the help of TLC – “tender loving care” ! Remember, “ HLA sharing between partners causes miscarriage” is a theory which not has not been proven. Please question your doctor if he pressurizes you to undergo treatment which is unproven and whose safety is not tested properly. 

I wish doctors would stop demoralizing infertile women with scary unproven theories and therapies !

“Just because an idea is true doesn't mean it can be proved. And just because an idea can be proved doesn't mean it's true.”

― Jonah Lehrer



18 comments:

  1. Hi manju...excellent research. Thank u for bringing light to this subject. I am just wondering aloud...here it goes: Shouldnt HLA match between couples cause implantation failures only? Is there any study that indicates how far along an embryo survives with such a condition? I cant remember where i read but there was a study somewhere which said that HLA matching couples would have a diminishing gestational survival weeks ultimately leading upto not implanting at all!
    Could you also let us know what These tests are called as?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Zeus,

      HLA matching between partners will not cause implantation failure! I agree that there are scientific studies on that but randomized controlled studies with sufficient strength are lacking. As of now there is no strong evidence to say HLA sharing between partners can cause implantation failures or recurrent abortions.

      Manju

      Delete
  2. There are lots of fertility clinics present all over India. There are numerous clinics in metropolitan cities like Mumbai, Delhi and Bangalore. It is said that more than 400 IVF clinics are present in India and they help to bring into being 30,000 ART treatments, every year.
    IVF Treatment in India
    Cost of IVF in India

    Best IVF Centres in India
    Surrogate mother agency in India

    ReplyDelete
  3. There are lots of fertility clinics present all over India. There are numerous clinics in metropolitan cities like Mumbai, Delhi and Bangalore. It is said that more than 400 IVF clinics are present in India and they help to bring into being 30,000 ART treatments, every year.
    IVF Treatment in India
    Cost of IVF in India

    Best IVF Centres in India
    Surrogate mother agency in India

    ReplyDelete
  4. This post has helped me very much. I have matches with my DH; 4 or 5 I believe. Dr. Braverman in NY has suggested I can only treat this with neupogen injections. He especially doesn't like the HLA-C matching. I don't want to take neupogen. I've never had implantation though and it does make one wonder. I suppose it could be the embryos but we've transferred 3 beautiful blasts on separate transfers and nothing. This was from a proven donor. The doctors find nothing wrong with me. I have one embryo left and will transfer in a couple of months again. This gives me hope that the matches are not doomsday. When we got the results it was interesting to see that my husband's 2 numbers for each type were identical. So he got the same number from each parent. If matches are really a problem then how did he get here? He is the 3rd son of 4! Congrats on your BFP! Best wishes for a successful delivery. Marie

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am happy that this post helped you. Definitely HLA sharing cannot be the reason for the lack of implantation. IVF need few attempts to be successful- 60% women conceive within 3 IVF cycles. I am very much surprised by the fact that what significance will your both HLA matching holds when a donor embryo is used ! There is no need to worry about HLA in your case. Neupogen is thought to improve implantation but no solid scientific proof again for it's use. It is thought to improve thin lining. I wish you lots of good luck, I am sure you will be successful.

      Manju

      Delete
    2. From what I've read the HLA matching is between the uterus and the sperm so in our case the donor egg that made up the embryo has no bearing on the matches my husband and I share. Am I understanding this wrong? Thanks for the info.

      Delete
    3. HLA matching is said to be a problem if you and your husband carry the same HLA haplotypes. This means the embryo or fetus that is formed will have identical HLA match to you (its mother). This is where the problem is thought to arise. But if donor egg is used, then the chance of the embryo carrying identical HLA match as yours is very, very less. Could you please read this para above : How does HLA comes into play in reproductive biology ? I hope this helps. I will try to put this in simple terms when possible.

      Delete
  5. Neupogen has a much more complex effect on sustaining pregnancy than just improving lining. This was a pretty stringent(if small) study on its effects with recurrent miscarriage: http://humrep.oxfordjournals.org/content/24/11/2703.full.pdf

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Manju: I was told that I have only one HLA mismatch and that I need neupogen therapy. I have been using a donor egg for IVF and had several failures. I have had one live birth, however, with my spouse. (This was donor egg IVF also).My question for you, is has many other women diagnosed with HLA matches gone on to have a successful pregnancy without immune treatments such as neupogen?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jan, you and your husband have HLA matching. You are using donor eggs. Does your donor and your husband share the same HLA matching as you both ? If not then how come the embryo will be rejected ( even if this HLA matching and embryo rejection theory holds true) by your uterus ? For example, you have HLA DQ which is smililar to your husband, your embryo will express similar HLA DQ on its surface and hence will be rejected ( as per this stupid hypothesis!). Now the embro formed has no chance of carrying your HLA genes, so the chance will be that the embryo will still be semi-allogenic which is perfectly fine. Could you understand what I am saying ? When an embryo is formed it will carry your HLA genes and your husband's. If both your HLA are similar, then there is a chance that the embryo has the same genetic makeup and hence it becomes isogenic and they claim it will be rejected. Now since you are using donor egg, the embryo still will still be semi- allogenic.

      If you need a simple answer, no HLA matching will not harm your donor egg pregnancy. You have experienced a donor egg pregnancy before and it is a proof for that. You do not need any therapy, perhaps you need a better doctor and clinic. May I know which doctor suggested you this ? Ask him what he knows about HLA matching and how it affects your chances?

      Delete
    2. Dr. Braverman (in New York) is the one who did my immunity testing and told me I needed neupogen for the HLA matching. I lost a baby (donor egg IVF) at 16 weeks and they said this is a classic immunology sign. Have had failed IVF transfers since then. He said the HLA matching problem can activate the T regulator cells, which then start attacking the fetus.

      Delete
    3. Jan, do one thing. Ask Dr. Braver man to explain you clearly how a donor egg pregnancy will be harmed if you and your husband share HLA. Will you please do it and send me the reply. My mail id is manjupadmasekar@yahoo. com. Might be his reply will educate me, if I am wrong.

      How many IVF transfers have you failed since then ? Is it with same donor ? How old is your donor ? Was the fetus genetically normal ? When did the fetus stopped growing ? Did you find it at 16 weeks or did the fetus stopped growing at 16 weeks ? Jan, I am really sorry you have to go through this, I know how painful it can be.

      How much they are charging for neupogen therapy ? Will you please let me know the details, then I will answer you.

      Manju

      Delete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. OK I am sending you an email.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi manju.. Do u have any idea of intralipid.. Me and my dh share some hla allele.. I have been told to gi for ivig treatment.. But i believe its very risky.. How is intralipid. I had 2 miscarriages earlier and now i am not able to conceive

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi manju.. Thanks for the useful info.. I have 4 hla alleles matching with my partner.. And i was advised to have ivig.. Which is very risky.. How is intralipid.. It is less costly and no side effects.. Could u please let me know about this

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If I were you , I will not get treated at all. If you want to be treated , if it would give you peace of mind , then opt for intralipid. IVIG is human serum and it carries the risk of infection and allergy.

      Delete

Please do write to me! It makes me happy :)

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...